Cover image for public collection
American Classic Rental

American Classic Rental

American Classic Rental is temporarily on pause as we restructure the company to better serve the Geneva Lakes' area. We will definitely be back soon bigger and better with another group of premium cars to provide incredible experiences. Stay tuned for our reopening.


Todd Reed
The car was exactly as advertised and performed great! Patrick and his crew are easy going and a pleasure to deal with. They have a great inventory of cars, I will certainly be back to rent again!
Aug 26, 2019
Arthur Sonneland
Incredible car, and the owner was so easy to work with and very accommodating. This car is a head turner and was perfect for our wedding.
Oct 7, 2019
Shaylyn El-Shahat
We had such a fun day using American Classic Rentals. We called on whim, looking for something fun to do for the day, and Sherm made the rental process incredibly easy. Within an hour we had the car and we were on the road. The car drove well and we spent the day cruising with the top down on the country roads. An afternoon well spent!
Jul 26, 2020
David Hayes
epic experience
Aug 8, 2020
Christopher Bradshaw
Smooth ride, great customer service. Will definitely be back!
Sep 7, 2020
Mike Martinez
I apologize for the late review, but wanted to say I had a wonderful time driving the GTO. Was definitely a great experience and will definitely be back to rent again.
Sep 15, 2020
Kaytlin Watts
Loved every minute! Customer service was truly the best of the best and my husband was so surprised. We had a great day in the car and look forward to being customers again soon.
Sep 7, 2020
Adam Varrassi
Terrific experience! Sherm was great to work with. Will definitely be recommending the Lake Geneva location!
Sep 12, 2020
Edward Shebel
This car is what dreams are made of people. Driving a 65 Shelby Cobra w at huge 427 is on every car enthusiasts bucket list. This tribute rocket left us with a permanent grin on our faces. Gorgeous car and the best way to enjoy Lake Geneva. Don’t settle for just a rental. Get something that sets the tone for an amazing getaway - and can turns heads with the crack of the throttle. The staff made the experience even better with their attention to detail. Thanks again for the memories! We will be back in the saddle Of this beast again soon!
Oct 4, 2020
Edward Shebel
The classic convertible car experience is the ONLY way to truly take in the sights and be seen. Anyone can rent a vanilla tin box with four wheels. These cars are vintage metal with four barrel carbs and the hypnotic note of big V8! The staff was excellent and very attentive to our needs and made the experience that much more enjoyable.
Oct 4, 2020
Brandon Smith
American Classic Rentals is a top-flight organization - and our rental of the C3 Corvette was not only convenient and efficient, but it was a tremendous amount of fun. We would highly recommend American Class Rentals to anyone looking for a great afternoon drive.
Oct 4, 2020
Erin Murphy
We rented the 1965 chevelle for our wedding day. We had the top down and cruised the back roads to Milwaukee on a perfect fall day. It was a great ride that left us wanting an old car. The owner assisted us with the booking and follow up. He was punctual, fair, and clear with communication. Onsite staff was friendly and informative. I’ll be back to test out the other cars :)
Oct 13, 2020
Bronson Dernay
Jun 23, 2021
Chris Bandstra
Wow, what a car! The 1965 Shelby cobra was so much fun. I couldn’t stop smiling for the entire drive. We bundled up since it was about 55 degrees today but well worth it. Definitely an experience I’m glad I was able to do. Owner was great to work with. Good communication and nice guy. Would highly recommend.
May 8, 2021
Greg Strom
The gift of the 2-hour rental was a celebration of my 70th birthday from my daughters. I had a '64 GTO when I was in college so the experience was one I was looking forward to. The car was a dream to drive. It is well cared for, spotless, well maintained and a real head-turner. Pick up was simple, efficient and pleasant. We couldn't get the radio to work but who needs the radio when you're enjoying the ride with the top down, enjoying the beautiful WI scenery and riding with a very pretty girl (my wife of 48+ years).
Jun 23, 2021
Jeff Bizub
This experience was amazing the car was exactly as described, the rental process was simple and straightforward and Sherm was great to work with and flexible on the pickup location. Would highly recommend to anyone in this area.
May 25, 2021
Michael Sambar
Awesome car and friendly, no-hassle service!
Jun 7, 2021
Luke Palmer
Great company to work with. Smooth check-in and check-out process. Friendly people. The car was in amazing condition and super fun to drive. Would work with again! A+ experience.
Jun 7, 2021
Pc ByAt
Great customer service from pre-booking to vehicle return. They made sure the process was quick and easy. Any questions I had were answered quickly. They took the time to explain everything about this Beautiful car. The experience was amazing. Seeing the smile on my dad's face as he rode in it was priceless.
Jun 21, 2021
Michael Semenow
Had an awesome time taking my boys out on the road. Fun car to drive
Jun 17, 2021
Joel Wendt
Great experience. AmericanClassic Rentals did a great job, they were very accommodating and easy to work with.
Jun 20, 2021
Heather Bartmes
Easy and fun! Thank you for a great experience being able to drive my husband's dream car.
Jun 25, 2021
Kate Civiletta-Kalich
Excellent experience. Efficient pick-up and drop-off. Great, fast, kind service. Car was in excellent condition! Had a fun time. The only thing I’d mention is that the fuel gage was inoperative. It read as ‘full’ when we left, stayed ‘full’ for the entire drive. When we filled up the car, we put in over 12 gallons after we went only 51 miles. Such is the case with classic vehicles! Just don’t go cruising too far unless you’re sure it’s full, so you’re not caught in a lurch. :)
Jul 2, 2021
Brad DeSent
Everything worked as expected. The process was easy and we really enjoyed driving around the area in the car. Thanks to the team. Brad D.
Jul 24, 2021
Common assessment
Based on selected review(s)
Filter reviews
American Classic’s collection
User authorization
Password recovery